E1 - Dejay, Malik & Josiah

Aired: February 24, 2016

Nev and Max get two catfishes for the price of one when they discover that Dejay and Malik are being played by the same guy. Sparks fly as they discover just how explosive a love triangle can be.

E2 - Jeanette & Derick

Aired: March 02, 2016

A concerned daughter asks for help when her mother begins contemplating marriage to a man she met online.

E3 - Leuh & Justin

Aired: March 09, 2016

After two failed attempts to meet up with a surfer, a woman wants to find out if he is actually the man of her dreams.

E4 - Brandon & McKenna

Aired: March 17, 2016

Karrueche Tran helps track down the truth when Brandon wonders whether his online love is real.

E5 - Jaylin & Ja’la

Aired: March 23, 2016

Jaylin is prepared to sacrifice a lifelong friendship and promising videogame career to be with a woman he’s never even spoken to on the phone. Nev and Max help him discover that sometimes the truth is stranger than fiction.

E6 - Michael & Chanelle

Aired: March 30, 2016

Michael felt he had no time for a relationship, but love appeared in a DM. Chanelle is the light he’s needed in his life, but out of the blue she's disappeared, leaving only Nev and Max to help him find his missing love.

E7 - Ray & Lexi

Aired: April 06, 2016

Ray is determined to finally meet his online love of four years, Lexi. But after learning that Lexi’s sister has meddled in the relationship in the past, Nev and Max soon find themselves with more questions than answers.

E8 - Joanna & Bo

Aired: April 13, 2016

Tattoo model, Joanna, was about to meet her online love in the flesh, but a crazy night in Vegas caused the whole relationship to go sour. Now she's enlisted Nev and Max to help track down her former flame and make things right.

E9 - Tyreme & Tomorrow

Aired: April 20, 2016

Tyreme met the beautiful Tomorrow online over 9 months ago. They share a deep bond and Tyreme is ready to uproot his life to be with her. Will Nev and Max be able help Tyreme finally meet his Tomorrow?

E10 - Kayla & Courtney

Aired: April 27, 2016

When Kayla was two, her father killed her mother and then later committed suicide. Years later, Kayla is sent a message from Courtney, a woman claiming to be channeling her dead father’s spirit.

E11 - Paris & Tara

Aired: May 04, 2016

Paris enlists Nev and Max to help her figure out who has been catfishing her for the past four years. But as the guys investigate, they make a shocking discovery that casts suspicion onto Paris herself!

E12 - Vince & Alyssa

Aired: May 11, 2016

Vince can’t seem to escape his online-ex, Alyssa, whose stalking has caused his real life girlfriend, Liz, to break up with him. Nev and Max help Vince confront Alyssa so he can try to salvage a future with Liz.

E13 - Lucas & Many

Aired: August 10, 2016

When Jayme learns that her online boyfriend is fake and that he is catfishing other women as well, she enlists the help of Nev and Max to stop him.

E14 - Larissa & Anthony

Aired: August 10, 2016

After being catfished by her best friend from high school, Larissa turns to another online friend for support.

E15 - Spencer & Katy

Aired: August 17, 2016

Spencer reveals that he has been having a relationship with a pop star, and the Catfish team sets out to find the truth.

E16 - Candic & Titus

Aired: August 24, 2016

After months of intimate text exchanges with a man she met online, named Titus, Candic has decided to finally stop and fess up to her husband. But before she does, she needs Nev and Max to help her find out who Titus really is!

E17 - Andrea, Alex & Andrea

Aired: August 31, 2016

Fans of popular YouTube star, Andrea Russett, summon Nev and Max to help catch a potential stalker who is impersonating Andrea's family online. The guys soon uncover a web of fake profiles much larger than they thought possible.

E18 - Catherine & Graham

Aired: September 07, 2016

Long Islander Catherine has fallen deeply in love with country boy Graham from Tennessee. She's ready to uproot her life to be a country girl with him, but Nev and Max uncover that Graham's not everything he claims to be.

E19 - Luis & Sydney

Aired: September 14, 2016

Luis has fallen in love with a single mom who is down on her luck and now he's ready to take their online relationship to the next level. But first, Nev and Max must help investigate.

E20 - Andrew & Zac

Aired: September 21, 2016

Andrew thought he met the perfect match on Tinder in Zac until he received a text message from a friend revealing shocking new information. As Nev and Max look into the case, they suspect Zac could be keeping a very big secret.